1343 Views
136 Downloads |
The characteristics and effects of public participation in Croatian e-consultations in fiscal matters
Article | Year: 2023 | Pages: 71 - 87 | Volume: 47 | Issue: 1 Received: April 24, 2022 | Accepted: September 7, 2022 | Published online: March 6, 2023
|
FULL ARTICLE
FIGURES & DATA
REFERENCES
CROSSMARK POLICY
METRICS
LICENCING
PDF
Traditional government departments
|
Administrative organizations by function
|
Social
|
Technical
|
Economic
|
Ministries of
|
Finance
Defence
Internal Affairs
Justice
State Property
Public Administration
|
Science and Education
Health
Culture
Work and Pension system
Demography, Family, Youth and Social Policy
Croatian War Veterans
|
Environment and Energy
Construction and Spatial Planning
Maritime Affairs, Transport and Infrastructure
|
Economy, Entrepreneurship and Crafts
Ministry of Agriculture
Ministry of Tourism
Ministry of Regional Development and EU funds
|
State administration organizations
|
State Administration Organization for Civil
Protection
State Administration Organization for Radiological
and Nuclear Safety
|
State Institute for Intellectual Property
|
State Geodetic Administration
|
State Meteorology Institute
|
Agencies
|
Croatian Agency for the Oversight of Financial
Services
Croatian National Bank
|
Croatian Agency for Health Insurance
|
Croatian Energy Regulatory agency
Croatian Regulatory Authority for Network Industries
Croatian Civil Aviation Agency
|
|
|
Duration (average, days)
|
Clarity
(median value 1-4)
|
Number of
|
Acceptance rate of comments (%)
|
E-consultations
|
Participants
|
Comments
|
Ministry of Finance (MF)
|
19.8
|
1
|
105
|
736
|
1,543
|
34.8
|
Traditional governmental departments (TGD)
|
23.2
|
1
|
606
|
2129
|
6,016
|
34.3
|
State-level administrative organizations (SAO)
|
24.8
|
1
|
1.643
|
13,615
|
32,906
|
23.8
|
Source: Authors based on data collected by Đurman (2019).
|
Duration (average)
|
Number of
|
Acceptance rate of comments (%)
|
E-consultations
|
Participants
|
Comments
|
Ministry of Finance (MF)
|
19.1
|
230
|
1,285
|
2,638
|
29.4
|
Source: Authors.
|
Ministry of Finance
(MF)
|
State-level administrative organizations
(SAO)
|
Interested public (participants)
|
Individuals
|
42.7
|
50.0
|
Chambers
|
16.8
|
5.9
|
Private sector organizations
|
15.6
|
10.0
|
CSO
|
15.2
|
17.2
|
Public companies
|
3.0
|
6.2
|
Other
|
6.7
|
10.7
|
Type of comments
|
Technical
|
13.6
|
28.8
|
Attitudes
|
28.6
|
21.9
|
Reasoning
|
15
|
22.1
|
Very well reasoned
|
40.8
|
22.9
|
Other
|
2
|
4.3
|
Status of comments
|
Accepted
Completely
Partially
|
34.8
26.6
8.2
|
23.8
15.7
8.1
|
Not accepted
|
32.6
|
43.5
|
Noted
|
32.1
|
28.1
|
No response
|
0.6
|
4.7
|
Source: Authors based on data collected by Đurman (2019).
Bronić, M., 2013. Koliko su otvoreni proračuni hrvatskih lokalnih jedinica. In: A. Musa, ed. Transparentnost - kako i zašto. Zagreb: Institut za javnu upravu ; Friedrich Ebert Stiftung, pp. 27-42.
Budget Law, Official Gazette 144/21.
Đurman, P., 2019. Utjecaj organizacijskih varijabli na process i rezultate participacije u javnoj upravi. Doctoral dissertation. Zagreb: Faculty of Law.
Ðurman, P., 2020. Savjetovanje s javnošću u pripremi propisa u Hrvatskoj. Zbornik Pravnog fakulteta u Zagrebu, 70(2-3), pp. 407-444 [ CrossRef]
Đurman, P., Musa, A. and Koprić, I., 2022. Participatory lawmaking in the digital age: the case of the e-public consultations platform in Croatia. In: T. Randma-Liiv and V. Lember, eds. Engaging Citizens in Policy Making: e-Participation Practices in Europe. Cheltenham, UK ; Northampton, MA, USA: Edward Elgar Publishing, pp. 91-103.
Džinić, J., 2021. Participativno budžetiranje u službi razvoja dobrog lokalnog upravljanja. In: I. Koprić and F. Staničić, eds. Referendum i deposredna demokracija u Hrvatskoj. Zagreb: Institut za javnu upravu, pp. 215-246.
Information Commissioner, 2021. The Report on the Implementation of the Law on the Right to Access Information. Zagreb: Information Commissioner.
Koprić, I. [et al.], 2014. Upravna znanost - Javna uprava u suvremenom europskom kontekstu. Zagreb: Pravni fakultet Sveučilišta u Zagrebu.
Koprić, I., 2017. Demokracija, decentralizacija, povjerenje građana i ponos javnih službenika: stari i novi koncepti u razvoju odnosa građana i javne uprave. In: I. Koprić, A. Musa, and T. Giljević, eds. Građani, javna uprava i lokalna samouprava: povjerenje, suradnja, potpora. Zagreb: Institut za javnu upravu, pp. 3-27.
Koprić, I., 2019. Novi zakoni o državnim službenicima i o sustavu državne uprave – osnovne primjedbe. Hrvatska i komparativna javna uprava/Croatian and Comparative Public Administration, contribution to the No. 2/2019, pp. 7-14.
Law on the right to access information, Official Gazette 25/13 and 85/15.
Law on the State Administration System, Official Gazette 66/19.
Lopižić, I. and Manojlović Toman, R., 2019. Prethodna evaluacija ukidanja ureda državne uprave u županijama. Zbornik Pravnog fakulteta u Zagrebu, 69(5-6), pp. 835-870 [ CrossRef]
Manojlović Toman, R. and Vukojičić Tomić, T., 2018. Načelo demokracije Europske povelje o lokalnoj samoupravi i sudjelovanje građana u hrvatskoj lokalnoj samoupravi. In: I. Koprić, A. Musa, and T. Giljević, eds. Građani, javna uprava i lokalna samouprava: povjerenje, suradnja, potpora. Zagreb: Institut za javnu upravu, pp. 343-371.
Milošević, B., 2017. Decentralizacija i poverenje građana: aktualna pitanja i problemi. In: I. Koprić, A. Musa, and T. Giljević, eds. Građani, javna uprava i lokalna samouprava: povjerenje, suradnja, potpora. Zagreb: Institut za javnu upravu, pp. 153-194.
Musa, A., 2017. Informacije za građane: transparentnom i otvorenom javnom upravom prema boljem upravljanju i povjerenju građana In: I. Koprić, A. Musa, and T. Giljević, eds. Građani, javna uprava i lokalna samouprava: povjerenje, suradnja, potpora. Zagreb: Institut za javnu upravu, pp. 29-72.
Musa, A., Đurman, P. and Hadaš, P., 2021. Otvoreni podaci javne uprave i lokalne samouprave. In: I. Koprić and F. Staničić, eds. Referendum i neposredna demokracija u Hrvatskoj. Zagreb: Institut za javnu upravu, pp. 273-313.
Ott, K. and Bronić, M., 2017. Lokalna samouprava i građani: Proračunska transparentnost lokalnih jedinica - Stavovi zaposlenika. In: I. Koprić, A. Musa, and T. Giljević, eds. Građani, javna uprava i lokalna samouprava: povjerenje, suradnja, potpora. Zagreb: Institut za javnu upravu, 477-502.
Schalk, J., 2015. Linking Stakeholder Involvement to Policy Performance: Nonlinear Effects in Dutch Local Government Policy Making. American Review of Public Administration, 47(4), pp. 1-23 [ CrossRef]
Van Loenen, B., Vancauwenberghe, G. and Crompvoets, J. (eds.), 2018. Open Data Exposed. T.M.C. Asser Press [ CrossRef]
Wampler, B., 2012. Entering the state: civil society activism and participatory governance in Brazil. Political Studies, 60(2), pp. 341-362 [ CrossRef]
Wampler, B., McNulty, S and Touchton, M., 2021. Participatory Budgeting in Global Perspective. Oxford: Oxford University Press [ CrossRef]
|
|
March, 2023 I/2023
|