Institute of public finance
Public Sector Economics conference
Call for papers
LOGIN / REGISTER
Public Sector Economics
CURRENT ISSUE
PAST ISSUES
ABOUT PSE
FOR AUTHORS
ETHICAL GUIDELINES
CONTACT
Print page
Search box

727
Views



38
Downloads

The role of economic and political factors in budget forecasting errors: evidence from Turkey’s metropolitan municipalities for the period 2011-2022



Berat Kara*
Article   |   Year:  2025   |   Pages:  273 - 307   |   Volume:  49   |   Issue:  2
Received:  June 14, 2024   |   Accepted:  September 25, 2024   |   Published online:  June 7, 2025
Download citation        https://doi.org/10.3326/pse.49.2.5       


  1. Afonso, A. and Silva, J., 2012. The Fiscal Forecasting Track Record of the European Commission and Portugal. ISEG Economics Working Paper, No. 37/2012/DE/UECE [CrossRef]

  2. Agostini, S. J., 1991. Searching for a Better Forecast: San Francisco’s Revenue Forecasting Model. Government Finance Review, 7, pp. 13-16.

  3. Aizenman, J. and Hausmann, R., 2000. The Impact of Inflation on Budgetary Discipline. Journal of Development Economics, 63(2), pp. 425-449 [CrossRef]

  4. Alesina, A. and Paradisi, M., 2017. Political Budget Cycles: Evidence from Italian Cities. Economics & Politics, 29(2), pp. 157-177 [CrossRef]

  5. Allan, C. M., 1965. Fiscal Marksmanship, 1951-1963. Oxford Economic Papers, 17(2), pp. 317-327 [CrossRef]

  6. Asher, M. G., 1978. Accuracy of Budgetary Forecasts of Central Government, 1967-68 to 1975-76. Economic and Political Weekly, 13(8), pp. 423-432.

  7. Auld, D. A., 1970. Fiscal Marksmanship in Canada. The Canadian Journal of Economics, 3(3), pp. 507-511 [CrossRef]

  8. Bağdigen, M., 2002. How Accurate is Revenue Forecasting in Turkey? An Empirical Analysis. Yapi Kredi Economic Review, 13(2), pp. 29-37.

  9. Beckett-Camarata, J., 2006. Revenue Forecasting Accuracy in Ohio Local Governments. Journal of Public Budgeting, Accounting & Financial Management, 18(1), pp. 77-99 [CrossRef]

  10. Bee, A. and Moulton, S., 2015. Political Budget Cycles in U.S. Municipalities.  Economics of Governance, 16(4), pp. 379-403 [CrossRef]

  11. Benito, B., Guillamon, M.-D. and Bastida, F., 2015. Budget Forecast Deviations in Municipal Governments: Determinants and Implications. Australian Accounting Review, 25(1), pp. 45-70 [CrossRef]

  12. Bhattacharya, B. B. and Kumari, A., 1988. Budget Forecasts of Central Government Revenue and Expenditure: A Test of Rational Expectation. Economic and Political Weekly, 23(26), pp. 1323-1327.

  13. Bischoff, I. and Gohout, W., 2006. Tax Projections in German States - Manipulated by Opportunistic Incumbent Parties? Finanzwissenschaftliche Arbeitspapiere, No. 74.

  14. Bohn, F., 2010. Disinformation and Political Budget Cycles. 

  15. Bohn, F., 2011. Political Budget Cycles: Can Disinformation Explain Country Group Differences. 

  16. Botrić, V. and Vizek, M., 2012. Forecasting Fiscal Revenues in a Transition Country: The Case of Croatia. Zagreb International Review of Economics & Business, 15(1), pp. 23-36.

  17. Boukari, M. and Veiga, F. J., 2018. Disentangling Political and Institutional Determinants of Budget Forecast Errors: A Comparative Approach. Journal of Comparative Economics, 46(4), pp. 1030-1045 [CrossRef]

  18. Boylan, R. T., 2008. Political Distortions in State Forecasts. Public Choice, 136(3), pp. 411-427 [CrossRef]

  19. Bretschneider, S. and Gorr, W. L., 1992. Economic, Organizational, and Political Influences on Biases in Forecasting State Sales Tax Receipts. International Journal of Forecasting, 7(4), pp. 457-466 [CrossRef]

  20. Bretschneider, S. [et al.], 1989. Political and Organizational Influences on the Accuracy of Forecasting State Government Revenues. International Journal of Forecasting, 5(3), pp. 307-319 [CrossRef]

  21. Brogan, M., 2012. The Politics of Budgeting: Evaluating the Effects of the Political Election Cycle on State-Level Budget Forecast Errors. Public Administration Quarterly, 36(1), pp. 84-115.

  22. Brouthers, L. E., 1986. Parties, Ideology and Elections: The Politics of Federal Revenues and Expenditures Forecasting. International Journal of Public Administration, 8(3), pp. 289-314 [CrossRef]

  23. Brück, T. and Stephan, A., 2005. Do Eurozone Countries Cheat with their Budget Deficit Forecasts? European University Viadrina Working Paper Series, No. 2005,5.

  24. Buettner, T. and Kauder, B., 2015. Political Biases Despite External Expert Participation: An Empirical Analysis of Tax Revenue Forecasts in Germany. Public Choice, 164(3), pp. 287-307 [CrossRef]

  25. Calabrese, T. and Williams, D., 2019. Bias Associated with Centrally Budgeted Expenditure Forecasts. In: D. Williams and T. Calabrese. The Palgrave Handbook of Government Budget Forecasting. Cham: Palgrave MacMillan, pp. 201-215 [CrossRef]

  26. Couture, J. and Imbeau, L., 2009. Do Governments Manipulate Their Revenue Forecasts? Budget Speech and Budget Outcomes in the Canadian Provinces. In: L. M. Imbeau. Do They Walk Like They Talk? Speech and Action in Policy Processes. New York: Springer, pp. 155-166[CrossRef]

  27. Davis, J. M., 1980. Fiscal Marksmanship in the United Kingdom, 1951-78. The Manchester School, 48(2), pp. 187-202 [CrossRef]

  28. Deus, J. D. and de Mendonça, H., 2017. Fiscal Forecasting Performance in an Emerging Economy: An Empirical Assessment of Brazil. Economic Systems, 41(3), pp. 408-419 [CrossRef]

  29. Deus, J. D. and de Mendonça, H. F., 2015. Empirical Evidence on Fiscal Forecasting in Eurozone Countries. Journal of Economic Studies, 42(5), pp. 838-860 [CrossRef]

  30. Fedotov, D. Y., 2017. Forecasting of Regional Economic Development and Budget Based on the Example of Irkutsk Oblast. Studies on Russian Economic Development, 28(4), pp. 416-422 [CrossRef]

  31. Feenberg, D. [et al.], 1989. Testing The Rationality of State Revenue Forecasts. The Review of Economics and Statistics, 71(2), pp. 300-308 [CrossRef]

  32. Forrester, J. P., 1991. Budgetary Constraints and Municipal Revenue Forecasting. Policy Sciences, 24(4), pp. 333-356 [CrossRef]

  33. Fullerton, T., 1989. A Composite Approach to Forecasting State Government Revenues: Case Study of the Idaho Sales Tax. International Journal of Forecasting, 5(3), pp. 373-380 [CrossRef]

  34. Gentry, W. M., 1989. Do State Revenue Forecasters Utilize Available Information? National Tax Journal, 42(4), pp. 429-439 [CrossRef]

  35. Geys, B., Goeminne, S. and Smolders, C., 2008. Political Fragmentation and Projected Tax Revenues: Evidence from Flemish Municipalities. International Tax and Public Finance, 15(3), pp. 297-315 [CrossRef]

  36. Grizzle, G. and Klay, W. E., 1994. Forecasting State Sales Tax Revenues: Comparing the Accuracy of Different Methods. State & Local Government Review, 26(3), pp. 142-152.

  37. Haan, J. D., and Mink, M., 2005. Has the Stability and Growth Pact Impeded Political Budget Cycles in the European Union? CESifo Working Paper Series, No. 1532 [CrossRef]

  38. Heinemann, F., 2006. Planning or Propaganda? An Evaluation of Germany’s Medium-term Budgetary Planning. FinanzArchiv / Public Finance Analysis, 62(4), pp. 551-578 [CrossRef]

  39. Holm-Hadulla, F., Hauptmeier, S. and Rother, P., 2012. The Impact of Expenditure Rules on Budgetary Discipline over the Cycle. Applied Economics, 44(25), pp. 3287-3296 [CrossRef]

  40. Islam, A. R., 1999. Forecast Performances of Provincial Government Revenue Estimates in Canada. Simon Fraser University, Doctoral Thesis.

  41. Jena, P. R., 2006. Fiscal Marksmanship: Link between Forecasting Central Tax Revenues and State Fiscal Management. Economic and Political Weekly, 41(37), 3971-3976. 

  42. Jones, V. D., Bretschneider, S. and Gorr, W., 1997. Organizational Pressures on Forecast Evaluation: Managerial, Political, and Procedural Influences. Journal of Forecasting, 16(4), pp. 241-254 [CrossRef]

  43. Kara, B., 2024a. The Performance of Medium-Term Budgeting in Türkiye: An Analysis of Budget Forecasts. Yönetim ve Ekonomi Dergisi, 31(4), pp. 659-676 [CrossRef]

  44. Kara, B., 2024b. Türkiye'de Kamu Bütçesi Tahminlerinin Gerçekliği. Ankara: Gazi Kitabevi.

  45. Kauder, B., Potrafke, N. and Schinke, C., 2017. Manipulating Fiscal Forecasts: Evidence from the German States. CESifo Working Paper, No. 6310 [CrossRef]

  46. Khan, A., 2019. Fundamentals of Public Budgeting and Finance. Palgrave Macmillan [CrossRef]

  47. Khan, T., Hussain, A. and Malik, Z. K., 2018. Fiscal Marksmanship in Pakistan: With Special Focus on Province Khyber Pakhtunkhwa. Pakistan Journal of Economic Studies, 1(1), pp. 21-43.

  48. Krause, G. A. and Corder, J., 2007. Explaining Bureaucratic Optimism: Theory and Evidence from U.S. Executive Agency Macroeconomic Forecasts. The American Political Science Review, 101(1), pp. 129-142 [CrossRef]

  49. Krol, R., 2013. Evaluating State Revenue Forecasting under a Flexible Loss Function. International Journal of Forecasting, 29(2), pp. 282-289 [CrossRef]

  50. Lago-Peñas, I. and Lago-Peñas, S., 2008. Explaining Budgetary Indiscipline: Evidence from Spanish Municipalities. Public Finance and Management, 8(1), pp. 1-43 [CrossRef]

  51. Lalvani, M., 1999. Elections and Macropolicy Signals: Political Budget Cycle Hypothesis. Economic and Political Weekly, pp. 2676-2681.

  52. Larkey, P. and Smith, R., 1989. Bias in the Formulation of Local Government Budget Problems. Policy Sciences, (22), pp. 123-166 [CrossRef]

  53. Lazar, C. and Andrei, J., 2006. The Budget - an Instrument for Forecasting. Multiyear Budgeting. Economic Insights – Trends and Challenges, 3, pp. 41-46.

  54. Leal, T. [et al.], 2008. Fiscal Forecasting: Lessons from the Literature and Challenges. Fiscal Studies, 29(3), pp. 347-386 [CrossRef]

  55. Lee, T.-H. and Kwak, S., 2020. Revenue Volatility and Forecast Errors: Evidence From Korean Local Governments. Local Government Studies, 46(1), pp. 1-16 [CrossRef]

  56. Mayper, A. G., Granof, M. and Giroux, G., 1991. An Analysis of Municipal Budget Variances. Accounting, Auditing & Accountability Journal, 4(1), pp. 29-50 [CrossRef]

  57. McCollough, J. and Frank, H., 1992. Incentives for Forecasting Reform Among Local Finance Officers. Public Budgeting and Financial Management, 4(2), pp. 407-429.

  58. Merola, R. and Pérez, J., 2013. Fiscal Forecast Errors: Governments versus Independent Agencies? European Journal of Political Economy, 32, pp. 285-299 [CrossRef]

  59. Mink, M. and de Haan, J., 2006. Are There Political Budget Cycles in the Euro Area? European Union Politics, 7(2), pp. 191-211 [CrossRef]

  60. Oliver, X. and Villalonga, J., 2018. The Determinants of Regional Budget Forecast Errors in Federal Economies: Spain 1995-2013. Hacienda Pública Española / Review of Public Economics, 226(3), pp. 85-121 [CrossRef]

  61. Penner, R. G., 2001. Errors in Budget Forecasting. Washington D.C.: The Urban Institute.

  62. Pina, Á. M. and Venes, N., 2011. The Political Economy of EDP Fiscal Forecasts: An Empirical Assessment. European Journal of Political Economy, 27(3), pp. 534-546 [CrossRef]

  63. Reddick, C. G., 2008. Evaluating Revenue Forecasting in City Governments: A Survey of Texas Finance Directors. In: J. Sun and T. Lynch. Government Budget Forecasting Theory and Practice. New York: Taylor & Francis Group, pp. 305-324 [CrossRef]

  64. Ríos, A.‐M. [et al.], 2018. The Influence of Transparency on Budget Forecast Deviations in Municipal Governments. Journal of Forecasting, 37(4), pp. 457-474 [CrossRef]

  65. Schroeder, L., 2007. Forecasting Local Revenues and Expenditures. In: A. Shah. Local Budgeting. Washington: The World Bank, pp. 53-79 [CrossRef]

  66. Sedmihradská, L. and Čabla, A., 2013. Budget Accuracy in Czech Municipalities and the Determinants of Tax Revenue Forecasting Errors. Ekonomická revue - Central European Review of Economic Issues, 16(4), pp. 197-206 [CrossRef]

  67. Stevenson, W. J., 2012. Operations Management. New York: The McGraw-Hill Irwin.

  68. Strauch, R., Hallerberg, M. and Hagen, J., 2004. Budgetary Forecasts in Europe - the Track Record of Stability and Convergence Programmes. European Central Bank Working Papers, No. 307 [CrossRef]

  69. Sturm, J.-E., Jong-A-Pin, R. and de Haan, J., 2012. Using Real-Time Data to Test for Political Budget Cycles. KOF Working papers, No 12-313 [CrossRef]

  70. Voorhees, W., 2006. Consistent Underestimation Bias, the Asymmetrical Loss Function, and Homogeneous Sources of Bias in State Revenue Forecasts. Journal of Public Budgeting, Accounting & Financial Management, 18(1), pp. 61-76 [CrossRef]

  71. Williams, D. W. and Calabrese, T., 2016. The Status of Budget Forecasting. Journal of Public and Nonprofit Affairs, 2(2), pp. 127-160 [CrossRef]

  72. Willoughby, K. and Guo, H., 2008. The State of the Art: Revenue Forecasting in US State Governments. In: J. Sun and T. Lynch. Government Budget Forecasting: Theory and Practice. Taylor & Francis Group, pp. 27-42 [CrossRef]

  73. Zakaria, M. and Ali, S., 2010. Fiscal Marksmanship in Pakistan. The Lahore Journal of Economics, 15(2), pp. 113-133 [CrossRef]

   June, 2025
II/2025
In order to give you a better user experience, cookies have been stored on your computer.
Accept cookie     More information